top of page

Furry Companions vs. Tiny Humans: The Growing Trend of Choosing Pets Over Parenthood

As a devoted pet parent, one fervent wish resides in my heart - that I outlive my canine companions. Unlike the journey of raising human offspring, I am not nurturing my dogs to become independent adults, ready to venture into the world. My goal is to provide them a life of comfort, shielded from concerns about the future economy, climate change, or tomorrow's dinner menu. In this reflection, my husband and I acknowledge economic realities and the loss of freedom as deterrents from embracing human parenthood. This blog will delve into the prevalent reasons behind the escalating trend of young adults choosing pets over parenthood.

In recent years, a discernible trend has emerged among young adults - a preference for four-legged companions over the pitter-patter of little human feet. Survey results published by USAToday in 2023 revealed nearly 40% of dog owners opted for pet companionship over parenthood. Individuals increasingly find joy in pet parenting rather than grappling with the demanding responsibilities of raising children. Their reasons, as the survey suggests, include the high cost of raising children, the perceived ease of caring for dogs, and the simple fact that having children is not a priority at the moment. This shift prompts intriguing questions about societal changes, personal priorities, and the evolving dynamics of family. Let's explore the five main reasons more people are opting for pets over children.

1.    Lifestyle Considerations

One key factor influencing the decision to choose pets over parenthood is the evolving lifestyle of young adults. In an era characterised by fast-paced living, demanding careers, and limited personal time, the prospect of raising a child full-time may seem overwhelming. Pets offer companionship without the same level of time and responsibility. This sentiment aligns with a Psychology Today study where 38% of childless women felt that “raising a child demands too much energy and time.”

2.    Economic Realities 

The economic landscape, specifically financial considerations, has played a significant role in shaping the choices of young adults. The rising cost of living, student loan debts, and employment uncertainties make starting a family financially daunting. Pets, with their lower associated costs, provide a sense of family and companionship without the substantial financial burden of raising children. According to Forbes, the annual cost of raising a child is, on average, five times more than the average annual cost of caring for a pet.

3.    Changing Perspectives on Family

Traditional notions of family are undergoing a transformation. Young adults today perceive family structures differently, emphasising chosen relationships and companionship over the traditional nuclear family model. Pets seamlessly fit into this new paradigm, offering unconditional love and support without the complexities of human relationships. A 2023 UK-based Tinder ad depicted a smiling young couple with a dog in a pushchair, showcasing the evolving definition of family structures.

4.    Flexibility and Freedom

Choosing pets over parenthood allows individuals to maintain a higher degree of flexibility and freedom. Pets don't require constant supervision, daycare arrangements, or schooling decisions. This flexibility appeals to those who value the ability to travel, pursue personal interests, and maintain an active social life without the constraints of parental responsibilities. A Psychology Today study found that 49% of surveyed women believe "people with children are more stressed than those without children."

5.    Emotional Well-being

Research indicates that pets significantly contribute to their owners' emotional well-being. Whether you’ve chosen to be childless or it was chosen for you, the companionship, loyalty, and unconditional love provided by pets can help alleviate stress, reduce feelings of loneliness, and enhance overall mental health. As half of British women reach 30 without having kids the emotional fulfillment derived from pet ownership becomes a primary motivator in choosing pets over parenthood.

To conclude, the choice to prioritise pets over parenthood reflects a broader societal shift in values, lifestyles, and perspectives on family. As young adults navigate the challenges of the modern world, the companionship and joy offered by furry friends are increasingly becoming a preferred form of family. While the decision is deeply personal and varies from individual to individual, one thing is certain - the bond between humans and their pets continues to grow stronger, reshaping the traditional concept of family in the 21st century.

A Heartfelt Piece of Advice

If you're seeking purpose without planning to bring a human into this world (whether it by choice or chosen for you), consider channeling your additional time and energy into caring for the environment, animals, and the elderly. These entities possess similar endearing traits as children but without one of the significant responsibilities associated with human parenthood.

Share Your Perspective

We would love to hear from you! If you've chosen paws over hands, which of the reasons resonates with you the most? Vote in the poll below and share your thoughts. Feel free to elaborate on your choice in the comments section. Your insights can contribute to a better understanding of this fascinating shift in family dynamics.

Which of the reasons resonates with you the most?

  • Lifestyle considerations

  • Economic realities

  • Flexibility and freedom

  • Changing perspective of family

Note: Although data is primarily from UK and US research, the trend is undoubtedly prevalent in South Africa, as evidenced by major retail stores investing more in pet-related products and services.



bottom of page